« December 2008 | Main | February 2009 » Israel and Turkey, Again
By Micah Halpern
Sunday February 1, 2009 I've Been Thinking: Remember the spat between Turkey and Israel at the World Economic Forum in Davos? Peres: These things can happen between friends. Erdogan: Firstly, of course. There is no doubt that such arguments can happen between friends. But nobody can even speak to a tribe leader so loudly and in front of the international community, and not to the leader of the Republic of Turkey. Peres: I raised my voice. In fact my friends tell me that I have a quite voice. This has nothing to do with my relationship with the prime minister of the Republic of Turkey. I am very sorry for what happened today. Erdogan: I heard that you are going to hold a press conference. Peres: Not today, but tomorrow. Erdogan: If you express these sincere feelings, which I believe you will, in tomorrow's press conference, I assume this problem will be mostly overcome. Peres: Of course I will publicly express these remarks. In conclusion: Paying attention to what Erdogan said, we hear that the problem will be mostly overcome if Peres apologizes publicly. Erdogan stressed that nobody can even speak to a tribal leader the way Peres spoke to him. A massive personal injury was done here. Unfortunately, while the insult is real the foundation for the argument is false. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click.
A New Egypt
By Micah Halpern
Saturday January 31, 2009 I've Been Thinking: Yesterday, we saw a new Egypt. Egypt arrested two armed men outside a tunnel on the Egyptian side of Gaza as they were about to enter the tunnel in order to smuggle in weapons. The Egyptians are searching for seven people, some of whom escaped into the tunnel. Egypt pronounced that Hezbollah leader Sheik Hassan Nasrallah was an Iranian agent. The pronouncement came as a response to a barrage of attacks made by Nasrallah during the Israeli operation in Gaza against Hamas. There is no love lost in the Arab world when it comes to Hamas. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Fighting in Davos
By Micah Halpern
Friday January 30, 2009 I've Been Thinking: The World Economic Forum in Davos is known for being a place of polite, high brow dialogue. Yesterday, Israeli President and Nobel Peace Prize winner Simon Peres was on a panel with President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey. By walking out, Erdogan lost credibility. By responding in the way in which he did, Peres was pitching to his own strengths. Shimon Peres excels in confronting liberals with liberal theory and reality couching it in the terms they understand best. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Same Old Iran
By Micah Halpern
Thursday January 29, 2009 I've Been Thinking: A new approach to Iran does not mean a new approach from Iran. Advisor to the president of Iran, Aliakbar Javanfekr, was recently quoted saying that Iran was not going to stop its nuclear development just because the United States asks them to stop. "We have no non-peaceful activities to suspend. All our activities are peaceful and under the supervision of the IAEA." Javanfekr had his own take on what has become one of the most quotable quotes from the Obama inauguration speech. There may be a new administration in Washington, DC, but it is the same old leadership running Iran. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Obama on Al Arabiyah
By Micah Halpern
Wednesday January 28, 2009 I've Been Thinking: President Obama's first TV interview was with Al Arabiyah. I watched the Obama interview several times and I read the transcript. Here's why I disagree with those comments: I hope that President Obama pays attention to his daily early morning security briefings. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Carter Does it Again
By Micah Halpern
Tuesday January 27, 2009 I've Been Thinking: Jimmy Carter is at it once again. Carter asserted two un-imaginables. Well Mr. Former President, Hamas lied to you and you believed them. I cannot fathom how Jimmy Carter comes up with these ideas. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. A TRUCE BY ANY OTHER NAME: HUDNA & TAHADIYAH
By Micah Halpern
Monday January 26, 2009 Column: Israel is proposing an eighteen month truce with Hamas. Hamas is asking for a twelve month period of quiet with Israel. So what's it gonna be? It's gonna be a serious problem. As the prison guard in the movie Cool Hand Luke so eloquently put it: "What we have here is a failure to communicate." What we have in this particular case is failure to communicate on two levels. Level one deals exclusively with Hamas. Truce, cease fire, deal - these notions are all anathema in Hamas' understanding of Islam. In Arabic culture conflict can be resolved in only two ways. One way is Hudna. Hudna has a deep historical and theological history. The second way is Tahadiyah. In contrast, Tahadiyah has no theology and absolutely no history outside of modern, contemporary events. Both terms have been bantered about, both have been mistranslated. Neither Hudna nor Tahadiyah means what politicians in Washington DC, the United Nations and European capitals think they mean. Hudna is a concept best described as a tactical response to being out numbered and out armed. As opposed to admitting to losing in conflict, Hudna is a move that permits the fighting to be halted in order to be continued on another day. One strikes a Hudna in order to regroup, rearm and then, most importantly, to attack and vanquish the party that you struck a treaty with. Hudna has a built in time limit of 10 years, but it may be renewed. It is far from anything we would consider to be a truce. As a classic form of Islamic diplomacy Hudna was first introduced by the prophet Mohammed when, according to the Koran in the 48th Sura known as "The Victory," Mohammed engages in an agreement with the tribe of Quraysh. The story begins in Medina. Mohammed takes 1500 men and marches on Mecca, his native city. He is confronted by an army that is far superior to his own from the tribe of Quraysh at a place called Hudaiybiyah. It is at Hudaibiyah that the two parties agree on a ten year pact. But two years later, after building a bigger and better army Mohammed breaks the treaty, attacks and enters Mecca victorious. As the ten year pact or treaty was being negotiated, Mohammed's advisers, principally his general Umar ibn al Khatib, rejected the idea. The advisers called entering into a pact with the knowing intention of reneging on your word dishonorable. But the Prophet made it very clear that this was the way to proceed and so it was done. As an interesting aside, the Sura aka "The Victory" in Arabic is called Al Fath. It was no accident that the first Palestinian leader, Yasser Arafat, chose to name his organization Al Fatah after that very same Sura in the Koran. Tahadiyah has much less history. It is not a theological term, it is not in the Koran and there is no link to any decision or stratagem of Mohammed. As a modern Arabic term Tahadiyah simply means calm or lull. It is a very problematic term and it is the term that Hamas is using now in talking about the cessation of hostilities with Israel. Tahadiyah does not mean cease fire. A lull implies a reduction, not a stoppage, of aggression. The concept of Tahadiyah implies that there is plenty of wiggle room. Tahadiyah is not quiet nor is it a commitment to enforce a quiet. Quite to the contrary a Tahadiyah actually allows for attacks and a gradual increase of pressure and a change in the status quo over time. It is a very ambiguous and amorphous term that translates into a very ambiguous and amorphous status on the ground. Tahadiyah is a diplomatic Pandora's Box. Hudna is diplomatic double talk. It really makes no difference if the world-at-large believes that Israel and Hamas have a year long truce or an eighteen month long truce. In the end, the hostilities will resume when Hamas is ready for the hostilities to resume. And then, Israel had better be ready. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Iran Needs Uranium
By Micah Halpern
Sunday January 25, 2009 I've Been Thinking: Rumors have been circulating for some time now that Iran does not have enough uranium to continue with their enriching program and nuclear development. Saturday's Times (the British newspaper) reported that Iran is very short on uranium and now needs to buy it. This plan might succeed in stopping or at least slowing down Iran's nuclear development. But this is certainly worth trying. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. War Crimes- Israel or Hamas?
By Micah Halpern
Saturday January 24, 2009 I've Been Thinking: Israel is bracing itself and preparing a legal defense in the international courts that will charge them for war crimes. Article 147 of the Fourth Geneva Convention clearly defines war crimes as the "Willful killing, torture, or inhuman treatment, including .. willfully causing great suffering or serious injury to body or health, ... taking of hostages and extensive destruction and appropriation of property, not justified by military necessity and carried out unlawfully and wantonly." The International Committee of the Red Cross embellishes the Geneva Conventions saying "The parties to conflict must at all times distinguish between the civilian population and combatants in order to spare the civilian population and civilian property. Neither the civilian population as a whole nor individual civilians may be attacked." There will be a serious attack against Israel in the international courts of law but they will fail. The law is pretty cut and dry. Israel's behavior has been pretty transparent. What does become clear is that according to international law Hamas' actions perfectly fit the definition of war crimes. Sadly and perhaps ironically Hamas will not be brought before an international court for their crimes. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. George Mitchell As Special Envoy
By Micah Halpern
Friday January 23, 2009 I've Been Thinking: George Mitchell was just named Special Envoy to the Middle East in the Obama administration. After the announcement, I re-read the Mitchell Report. The Mitchell Report is brutally honest and sadly, not optimistic. Special Envoy Mitchell believes in an evenhanded approach. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Ghaddafi Asks Obama to Talk to Osama
By Micah Halpern
Thursday January 22, 2009 I've Been thinking: Advice for the new president is coming in from the four corners of the world. These are the words of wisdom of Libyan leader Muammar Ghadaffi to President Barack Obama: Yes, Ghaddafi was encouraging Obama to dialogue with bin Laden. Some things, you just can't make up. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Obama's Mid East Briefing
By Micah Halpern
Wednesday January 21, 2009 I've Been Thinking: The Obama administration will be a friend to Israel, of that I have no doubt, it is stated policy. But that does not mean that the new administration will not bring pressure upon Israel, especially if they take up the Middle East gauntlet at the start of the new administration. There is a lot to deal with in the region. This is part of what the new president will hear concerning the Middle East in his first security briefing as president: Some of these issues may seem to be non-sequiturs. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Inauguration and Coronation
By Micah Halpern
Tuesday January 20, 2009 I've Been Thinking: The inauguration of a first term president is the closest thing this side of the Atlantic of a royal ceremony - it is a coronation, USA style. In the days preceding the inauguration the president-elect is revered. The wheels of pomp and power move to create a transition of power that is seemingly seamless. A sense of excitement surrounds all inaugurations. The excitement surrounding the inauguration of Barack Obama is greater than all others in modern history. The emotional high, as I walk the streets of Washington DC, is palpable and contagious. People have come to our nation's capital from cities large and small all across America. The concerts are loud. The museums are packed. The vendors are hawking photos and maps and calendars and clothing. Everyone feels a part of history. Everyone feels a part of history-in-the-making. These moments in American history are laced with magic. When a democracy installs a leader it is an important occasion not only for that country but for the democratic world. When the most powerful democracy in the world installs a new leader it is important for the non-democratic world as well. The President of the United States of America is the leader of the free world. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Does The Islamic Society Support Hamas?
By Micah Halpern
Monday January 19, 2009 I've Been Thinking: We have a problem. The speaker's name is Ingrid Mattson. Here is the problem: Legal papers were filed by federal prosecutors in federal court in July of 2007 and the papers make a very convincing argument. The papers concerned a terrorism case from Dallas. Mattson's group is mentioned but not charged. Here's where it get more complicated: The Islamic society claims to be the largest mainstream Muslim organization in North America. Do they support Hamas even in word? I could not find it on their website. They certainly object to Israel's operation in Gaza and to civilian deaths, but that does not mean they are Hamas supporters. The status and mission of the Islamic Society of North America must be checked out by federal authorities, the record must be clarified. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Cease Fire Prediction
By Micah Halpern
Sunday January 18, 2009 I'm Predicting: Israel declared a unilateral cease fire as of 2 AM. Hamas has announced that they have no intention of ceasing fire. What we have here is a conflict that juxtaposes Western thinking with Middle Eastern mentality. I'm predicting that Hamas will continue to launch rockets into Israel throughout Sunday and even on Monday. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. No Israelis Allowed
By Micah Halpern
Saturday January 17, 2009 I've Been Thinking: The world has taken note of the Israeli operation in Gaza. Some of the responses are to be expected, others are certainly surprising, even shocking. However: In most democracies one may not discriminate against people because they come from a particular country or culture. But as we are seeing, local establishments are being given more leeway in putting out the Not Welcome mat. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Osama Bin Ladin Tape
By Micah Halpern
Friday January 16, 2009 I've Been Thinking: Osama bin Laden released a new audio tape. Bin Laden released this tape because he needs to show that: - He can be as forceful as Iran which has, until now, single handedly spearheaded the assault against everyone not in support of Hamas. - He cannot allow Shiite Iran to be the defender of Sunni Hamas. - He views what is happening as the perfect historical example of monarchs and dictators in the Muslim world with no real pan-Islamic ideals. He can use this opportunity to demonstrate that these leaders are more closely linked to the West than to the Islamic ideology of Hamas and al Qaeda. Bin Ladin knows the world of PR. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Cease Fire
By Micah Halpern
Thursday January 15, 2009 I'm Predicting: There have been positive signals about a cease fire between Hamas and Israel in Gaza, but we cannot read much into even those signals. Here's why: To paraphrase a Hamas spokesman: To quote him directly, in translation: Of course the list of Hamas reservations cannot be accepted. Let's get real. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. UN and Human Shields
By Micah Halpern
Wednesday January 14, 2009 I've Been Thinking: Ban Ki Moon is on his way to the Middle East. The Secretary General of the United Nations plans on using the weight of his august position to influence all parties in the region to push for a Gaza cease fire. I have been watching the Secretary very carefully since the beginning of this conflict. But on one of the most important moral and ethical issues of this conflict the Secretary General has remained utterly silent. If there is one role that the Secretary General of the United States is required to play it is that of international moral compass. It is the responsibility of the Secretary General to not only point out the moral and ethical shortcomings of nations but to also try to influence those nations to act morally. Ban Ki Moon has not said a word about Hamas' use of human shields. This is a severe blemish on the Secretary. When Hezbollah used human shields in the summer of 2006 the previous Secretary General of the United Nations, Kofi Annan, made it clear that such behavior was reprehensible. By not speaking out about the use of human shields Ban Ki Moon is allowing Hamas to appear as the innocent victims of Israel in this conflict. The implication is that the civilian casualties are the result of deliberate act of Israeli brutality. Speaking out against the policy of using human shields will not change Hamas' behavior but it will certainly show those who listen that Hamas cares only about the Islamic resistance and not about Palestinian lives. Sometimes, silence really does speak louder than words. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. THE IRANIAN / SYRIAN PRISM
By Micah Halpern
Tuesday January 13, 2009 Column: Iran and Syria see the world through their own prism. They keep each other's company, they enjoy each other's company, they support each other's diplomatic machinations, they don't trust each other one little bit and they certainly don't trust anyone else. For Iran and Syria, that's normal. Iran and Syria need to feel in charge. Ask Hamas and Hezbollah leaders and they will answer that they are independent entities, but observe Hamas and Hezbollah and you will know that they are ruled by the whim, whimsy and wealth of Iran. Ask the rulers of Lebanon and they will claim to be an independent country, watch what happens in Lebanon and you will see the guiding hand of Syria. It's a mutual admiration society - Iran applauds Syria, Syria applauds Iran and they both applaud Hamas and Hezbollah. Ali Larijani, the speaker of the Iranian parliament, just came back from a multi day trip to Syria and Lebanon. This was not a routine trip. This trip had a definite, specific purpose. Larijani went to gather information about Gaza, he wanted details on the Israeli operation against Hamas. Larijani is not your typical guest. He was Iran's chief nuclear negotiator. He is a master strategist. He and Iranian leader Ahmadinejad are a team, they might disagree on economic issues and Ahmadinejad may take issue with some minor tactics within the larger strategic plan that Larijani composed, but that has not compromised their alliance. If the Western world had been paying attention, if the Western world had bothered to monitor Larijani's comments during this trip, the Western world would have a better understanding of the rudder that guides Hamas. Instead, the Western world has averted its collective eyes, clogged its collective ears and turned oblivious to one of the most significant visits to take place in the Middle East in a long time. That's how we missed out on reacting to one of the most poetic descriptions delivered on the Egyptian/French cease fire proposal in Gaza. While in Lebanon, after meeting with Hezbollah, Larijani summed the initiative up by calling it "honey injected with poison." While in the Syrian capital Damascus Larijani met with Khalad Mashaal, the head of Hamas. Yes, the actual head of Hamas is not in Gaza, he is in Syria, living under the protection and sponsorship of the Syrian government. The Iranian/Hamas meeting lasted hours, it ran deep into the morning and when it was over, there were no official reports, no statements, no press conferences. Iran wanted details. Iran wanted specifics about Gaza - how much damage has been done, how strong is Hamas, how capable is Israel. Larijani was not interested in the mainstays of Arab conversation, rhetoric and hyperbole, he wanted cold, hard, facts, he wanted what the business world calls a real time assessment. For Larijani the situation in Gaza is a business deal turning sour. Mashaal was not interested in giving over information, Mashaal wanted Iranian support, even Iranian intervention. If he could not persuade the Iranians to enter the fray against Israel he was at least hoping for them to sanction and enable international terror strikes, if not that then to at lest unleash Hezbollah rockets upon Israel from the North forcing Israel into a two-front war. He got none of that. In return for information Iran promised to give money and to help rearm, retrain and rebuild their proxies - but they will not act. Iran will not jeopardize assets and push to the margins their larger objectives to help Hamas in a losing battle. Iran will serve as cheerleaders galvanizing Muslim support for Hamas and rally against Arab leaders, against Israel and against the West, against anyone helping Israel even by fiat or through acquiescence. Nothing more. Iran is taking the Israeli invasion of Gaza very seriously. So seriously that Larijani is not the only high ranking Iranian official to visit Syria and meet with Hamas and Hezbollah. Saeed Jalili, the secretary of Iran's Supreme National Security Council, also traveled to Syria and met with Syrian leader Bashar Assad. More importantly he met with Halad Mashaal and Ramadan Salah, the head of Islamic Jihad, the other terrorist group in Gaza. Jalili, not quite as poetic as Larijani, echoed a common Iranian theme, saying that "the Zionists are one step away from collapse." Syria and Iran are trying to spin the situation in Gaza, they are trying to figure out how to best manipulate world opinion against Israel. That's why Mashaal rejected all the cease fire proposals but demanded that Israel live up to the UN and Egyptian/French proposal. Is that seems like a contradiction it's only because you are analyzing the situation from a Western perspective. From the Iran/Syria/Hamas perspective the UN and Egyptian/French proposals are ammunition with which Israel can be attacked in the international arena. Gaza is not going away. Syria and Iran are not going to change. Hamas and Hezbollah are not going to give up. If we want to keep up with the situation, we had better start looking at it through the Iranian/Syrian prism. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. UN Cease Fire
By Micah Halpern
Monday January 12, 2009 I've Been Thinking: Much has been said about the UN Security Council's resolution for a cease fire in Gaza. The vote for the cease fire was 14 - 0. Why did the United States abstain? The resolution is deeply flawed. Here's what it does say: Article 8. calls for renewed and urgent efforts by the parties and the international community to achieve a comprehensive peace based on the vision of a region where two democratic states, Israel and Palestine, live side by side in peace with secure and recognized borders, as envisaged in Security Council resolution 1850 (2008), and recalls also the importance of the Arab Peace Initiative; Folding the Palestinian/Israel peace process into the Hamas conflict with Israel legitimizes Hamas, it de facto takes Hamas to a whole new level. The Israeli operation is not about peace with the Palestinians, it is about a terror group in Gaza shooting rockets at Israel. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Chemical Weapons in Gaza
By Micah Halpern
Sunday January 11, 2009 I've Been Thinking: The Times of London broke the story which then ran on Al Jazeera: The assumption is that Israel is using a chemical war agent and will be condemned world over for that action. Willy Pete, which is widely used in many forms is not illegal by any treaty nor is it one any list of chemical weapons. Willy Pete was first used in WWI by the British and then used very often in WWII. The US uses and actually, the battle in Fallujah went so well because of Willy Pete. Israel used it in Lebanon against Hezbollah and seems to be using it now against Hamas. The cover of a smoke screen saves lives. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Cease Fire With Hamas
By Micah Halpern
Saturday January 10, 2009 I've Been Thinking: The cease fire between Hamas and Israel is being hammered out on two fronts. About the UN: About the Egyptian/French Initiative: The reality is that Israel must not stop now. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. The Terror Risk: The Lone Wolf
By Micah Halpern
Friday January 9, 2009 I've Been Thinking: In Islam, Friday is the Sabbath, it is the day of rest. There are some mosques and some Imams who speak not only on Friday, but in every mosque the Imam delivers his main sermon on Friday. I will venture to bet that today, in almost every mosque around the world, Imams will be preaching about Gaza, Israel and the world. The implication of these sermons is particularly important. We must all be aware of the "lone wolf" phenomenon. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Gaza Operation: The End in Sight
By Micah Halpern
Thursday January 8, 2009 I'm Predicting: Now, well into the second week of the Israeli operation into Gaza, the head of emergency services in Gaza says the death toll has reached 700 and injuries 3,100. Here are some indicators: The details will take several days to work out. A new status with a severally weakened Hamas is close. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Chavez Expells Israeli Ambassador
By Micah Halpern
Wednesday January 7, 2009 I've Been Thinking: Chavez just expelled the Israeli ambassador from Venezuela. Chavez wanted to take a public stand against Israel and against the West. The act of expelling the Israeli ambassador because of the Gaza defense operation empowers Venezuela as a leader of the developing world. Many people, including the Israelis, are upset by the loss of human lives in Gaza. For Chavez this is more than an issue of innocent lives lost. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Accidents Happen
By Micah Halpern
Tuesday January 6, 2009 I've Been Thinking: Three Israeli soldiers have been killed and 24 have been wounded by friendly fire. It was devastating, but not surprising: This should not come as a surprise either: There is certainly no surprise here: Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Israel & Hamas: The End Game
By Micah Halpern
Monday January 5, 2009 I'm Predicting: The clear objectives of Israel's land operation are exactly the objectives of the aerial operation. Israel's prime objective is to secure a stable, sustainable quiet. I would predict that even after an agreement or a cease fire or a "lull" there will be a series of Hamas launchings into Israel just to prove that Israel did not totally destroy Hamas' caches of rockets. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Hamas: Lessons Learned
By Micah Halpern
Sunday January 4, 2009 I've Been Thinking: Hamas is beginning to feel the squeeze of the Israeli operation. Israel's army has sustained almost no serious casualties. Hamas leadership: The next few tomorrows: Implications for the Obama Presidency: Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Security Council Changes for the Better
By Micah Halpern
Saturday January 3, 2009 I've Been Thinking: A special session of the UN Security Council is being called to debate a critical resolution on Israel's operation in Gaza. The good news is that the Security Council changed over the past few days. Replacing Indonesia with Japan means replacing the world's most populated Muslim country with a country petrified of terror. Looking at it through Western eyes, things are looking up at the United Nations. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Hamas Will Hit Back
By Micah Halpern
Friday January 2, 2009 I'm Predicting: We are coming up on one week since Israel began their operation against Hamas. Hamas has been shooting back at Israel. Today is the Muslim Sabbath. Read my new book THUGS. It's easy. Just click. Powered by Movable Type Site design by Sekimori
|